Yet some performers I saw... already had all the gifts, material and charisma necessary for stardom, including… improv whirlwind Rachel Rosenthal, now drawing laughs regularly... in New York.
— Huffington Post
 
The last story by Rachel Rosenthal [is] the real tour de force… Rosenthal finds moments of humor in bleak circumstances, making her piece one that’s worth skipping ahead for…
— AV Club (Review of RISK! performance)